Ugh. This is so not my favorite technique. I ended up re-doing it, and while I'm still not thrilled with it, this is better than the first one I tried! I liked Smashley Sparkles' idea of using a glitter for the base color, so I used China Glaze I Herd That and tried two different colors on top of it. The darker color is China Glaze Foie Gras and the lighter color is China Glaze Desert Sun.
I don't think I will be trying any more saran wrap manicures anytime soon. Hopefully the other ladies had better luck than I did!